linked in facebook twitter rss

  • Interbrand
  • Brandchannel

your chance!
your chance!
Also of interest
     
  Model Behavior? Brands Beware
U.S. Legal Changes Impact Use of Brand Ambassadors

by Arthur Chinski and Joshua Mizrahi
March 11, 2014

Due to a recent increase in wage and hour claims in the entertainment industries, U.S. brands using models and spokespeople for their ads and marketing campaigns need to be conscious of how they treat talent who are not covered under a collective bargaining agreement. (This excludes celebrity spokespeople and supermodels that are covered under a SAG-AFTRA agreement, or one with the American Association of Advertising Agencies and/or the Association of National Advertisers). Failure to do so may expose a company to unnecessary, costly California Labor Code claims.

Companies often retain the services of talent through a talent agency. At times, a company will rely on an independent contractor photographer, advertising agency or director to obtain talent for a photo shoot or commercial advertisement. Typically, a claim filed by the plaintiff's bar will assert that the model or spokesperson who provided these advertisement services, even if only for a few hours, a day or a few days, was an employee of the company and not an independent contractor. Thus, he is not only entitled to overtime pay and all pay by a date established under the California Labor Code for employees, but also penalties related to violations of the pay provisions of the California Labor Code.

A company that terminates an employee must pay him all wages on the day of termination under Labor Code section 201. If it can be established the "employee is engaged in the production or broadcasting of motion pictures" or whose "job duties relate to or support the production or broadcasting" and who is hired "for a period of limited duration" including on the basis of one or more daily or weekly calls," then the Company must pay the employee by the "next regular payday" under Labor Code section 201.5. Under Labor Code section 201.5, "production or broadcasting of motion pictures" is further defined to include "commercial advertisements." Should an employer fail to make such payment, an employee is entitled to a continuation of wages for up to 30 days. Hence, if a model charges a fee of $1,000 per day and was not paid within 30 days of the end of the shoot, the model, if found to be an employee, arguably would be entitled to penalties in the amount of $30,000.

Attorneys for models and spokespeople are using Labor Code sections 201 and 203 and 201.5 and even Labor Code section 204 (sets forth a limitation on how often and when pay days must occur), as tools to squeeze exorbitant penalties out of companies, often offering to "settle" these cases for a much lesser amount than the full amount alleged to be owed.

To support their arguments, Plaintiffs rely primarily on a 1980 California Court of Appeal's case, Zaremba v. Miller, which held that professional photography models generally render their services as employees. That case involved a model who was hired by a photographer for a photo shoot that lasted two hours. The model obtained the job through her agent and her agent billed the photographer for the services once the model completed the shoot. The photographer failed to pay the model for five months. In defense of the claim, the photographer argued the model was an independent contractor and that it was customary in the industry to pay the model once the photographer was paid by the company. The Zaremba court did not accept these arguments and awarded the model waiting time penalties.

Hence, companies that use the services of a model or spokesperson, directly or through a photographer, director, or talent agency, should take important steps to avoid or minimize a finding by a court, or the California Division of Labor Standards Enforcement, that the company is actually the employer of the model. The most typical defense a company can assert is that the model or spokesperson is not an employee, but an independent contractor. In determining this, the most important factor a court or labor commissioner will analyze is whether the company had the right to control the means and manner of the job. In other words, if the company tells the model or spokesperson where to go, when to show up, what to wear, how to model or present whatever product the company manufacturers, what make-up to wear, what hairstyle to wear, and when to leave, it will be more likely that a plaintiff will be able to argue the company exerted enough control for it to be considered the employer.

Obviously, every case is different, so the decision will turn on specific facts. In some cases, a company will have very strong arguments the model or spokesperson truly is an independent contractor, and therefore, litigating the issue would be appropriate, particularly if the company sees this as an ongoing issue. In other cases, defense counsel's role would be to make the best possible arguments with the hope of gaining as much leverage as possible to force a more palatable settlement. Since these cases are fact intensive and many could go either way, the results of the independent contractor analysis will be the primary factor in determining whether or not a company will be liable for wages still owed and/or waiting time penalties.

Another defense companies can assert in waiting time penalty cases is that the failure to pay was not willful (i.e Labor Code section 203 requires a "willful" failure to pay by the employer) and that they had a "good faith belief" that the model was not an employee of the company. While asserting the "lack of willfulness" and "good faith belief" are proper defenses to penalties, labor commissioners who find that a company exerted enough control over a model or spokesperson to warrant a conclusion that they were, indeed, an employee are less likely to reduce or eliminate a sought-after penalty based upon these arguments. However, such defenses under the right set of facts are more likely to be given greater credence in a court proceeding.

In order to protect against these types of claims altogether, a company should exert as little control as possible over the model or spokesperson for an advertisement campaign. If that is not possible, a company should make arrangements with the talent agency or photographer to make payment to the model immediately or as otherwise required under the Labor Code (i.e. Labor Code section 201.3 allows for payment by a "temporary services employer" on a weekly basis and Labor Code 501.5, if applicable, the "next regular payday"). Companies should also have written agreements with the talent agencies and photographers supplying them with the model or spokesperson. These agreements should contain indemnity provisions in the event they fail to make a timely payment to the model or spokesperson.

Thus, the best practice is to make sure a company does not exert overly broad control over the model's or spokesperson's services. When this is unavoidable and a company could potentially be found to be an employer of the model or spokesperson, it is important to compensate them as quickly as possible upon completion of the assignment.

 
 

 
   
   Arthur Chinski is a Shareholder in Buchalter Nemer’s Labor & Employment Practice Group. He can be reached at achinski@buchalter.com.

Joshua Mizrahi is an Associate in the firm's Labor & Employment Practice Group. He can be reached at jmizrahi@buchalter.com.



 
 commenting closed Add Social Bookmark bookmark  print
 suggest topic  recommend ( 11 )  email

Model Behavior? Brands Beware
U.S. Legal Changes Impact Use of Brand Ambassadors

 
 Hey there! Do you know if they make any plugins to deegfdedafgddece 
Smithe435, John, nisesite - August 23, 2014
  brandchannel brandspeak archive   2014  |  2013  |  2012  |  2011  | 2010  |  2009  |  2008  |  2007  |  2006  |  2005  |  2004  |  2003  |  2002  |  2001
 
 
Dec 17, 2010 Advertising’s Trust Deficit and How to Address It -- Dan Hill
  Why consumers mistrust advertising — and what brands can do.
   
 
Dec 10, 2010 Branding for Men: Less Testosterone, More Thought, Please -- Fred Richards
  Brands have reverted to the tried-and-true formula of communicating to the lowest common denominator in order to reach men. Big mistake.
   
 
Dec 3, 2010 Mass Retail in India - Brands Beware or Brands Be Ready? -- Sid Shah
  The opportunity in India is huge, but can be a conundrum — there is exponential growth, but also fears of a lacking infrastructure and rampant piracy. What's a brand marketer to do?
   
 
Nov 19, 2010 Customer Satisfaction is Not Enough - Why High Satisfaction Scores May Actually Spell “Danger” for Your Brand -- Michael Hinshaw
  Michael Hinshaw discusses customer satisfaction.
   
 
Nov 11, 2010 Internal Brand Engagement - Turn Employees Into Brand Ambassadors, Not Automatons -- Fermi Kuruvilla
  Fermi Kuruvilla emphasizes the importance of engaging employees — one tear at a time
   
 
Oct 29, 2010 Brands in the Land of the Dwarfs -- Guy Weinberger
  Guy Weinberger, the CEO of Zarmon Goldman DDB, on how social media perceptions impact consumers and brands
   
 
Oct 22, 2010 Platform Wars – Who Will Win and Who Will Lose? -- Chris O'Hara
  Traffiq’s Chris O’Hara weighs in on the platform wars debate
   
 
Oct 15, 2010 Who’s Selling What to Whom? -- Claire Ratushny
  Claire Ratushny
   
 
Oct 8, 2010 Reinforcing Employee Engagement
  Dr. Hubert Rampersad looks at how to impart brand values to employees.
   
 
Oct 1, 2010 Brands Should Think of Social Media as a Party -- Avi Savar
  The founder & CEO of Big Fuel Communications shares his advice to clients on making their brands shine in the social media space.
   
 
Sep 24, 2010 Five Ways to Win Back Lapsed Customers -- Jim Wehmann
  Jim Wehmann, VP of global marketing for Digital River, on boosting customer engagement
   
 
Sep 17, 2010 A Tale of Two Boomer Campaigns -- Stephen Reily
  The CEO of VibrantNation.com shares his insights on what makes boomers tick, and click.
   
 
Sep 10, 2010 Nation Branding at the 2010 World Expo: A Matter of Balance -- Jay Wang
  University of Southern California professor Jay Wang weighs in on the 2010 World Expo in Shanghai, where he has been leading USC's research project on nation branding.
   
 
Aug 27, 2010 My Son, the YouTube Phenom -- Amy Mumby
  Amy Mumby, whose son Remy is a growing star on YouTube, talks about raising a personal branding star ... who's only ten years old.
   
 
Aug 20, 2010 Trust Me, I'm a Gamer -- Amanda Patanaphan
  My name is Amanda and I am a recovering World of Warcraft addict. Let me tell you why brand marketers should be paying attention to gaming.
   
 
Aug 13, 2010 Eat, Love, Share -- Ben Dehan
  Foodbuzz CEO Ben Dehan argues that Brand Awareness can and should be measured by Brand Engagement, not by display ad CTRs.
   
 
Aug 6, 2010 Business to Business as Usual -- Jonathan Katz
  Brand marketer Jonathan Katz finds brand identities in the B2B world are "meaningless, derivative, comfortable. We’ve been conditioned over the years to assume that these vacuous statements 'belong' in the business world." Wrong!
   
 
Jul 29, 2010 Your Brand Isn’t Selling? You’re Disconnected. -- Ted Mininni
  Retailers are concentrating on their store brands and giving shorter shrift to national brands and manufacturer partnerships.
   
 
Jul 23, 2010 The Four Imperatives of your Personal Brand -- Selena Rezvani
  Selena Rezvani, an author, speaker, and consultant on women and leadership, advises women on how to maintain their personal brands
   
 
Jul 16, 2010 Old Spice Man: An Open Letter -- Jeremy S. Griffin
  Social media strategist Jeremy S. Griffin responds to Old Spice's social media viral response campaign.
   
 
Jul 8, 2010 Hispanic Branding: Lost in Translation -- Joe Ray
  Estudio Ray president and creative director Joe Ray looks at common misconceptions in Hispanic branding and naming.
   
 
Jul 2, 2010 The Path to World-Class Packaging: The Annual Review -- Barbara Harrington
  Brandesign founder Barbara Harrington looks at whether packaging is a “line item” on an annual brand review -- and if not, why it should be.
   
 
Jun 25, 2010 Jumpstart E-Commerce Sales with Five Easy Tips -- Dimitri Onistsuk
  Shopify VP Dimitri Onistsuk shares advice on how businesses can jumpstart e-commerce sales in five steps.
   
 
Jun 18, 2010 Rebranding Inside and Out: How Trover Health System Changed Its Image -- Joseph Miller
  Trover Health System details its two-year, integrated approach to rebranding its hospital serving six counties in Western Kentucky.
   
 
Jun 11, 2010 Time to Re-think Brand Philippines? -- Robert Allen
  The election of Benigno ‘Noynoy’ Aquino as the Philippine’s new President marks both a progression and continuity in the country’s politics. Will this represent continuity or change for the country’s brand?
   
 
Jun 4, 2010 Lessons from the Downturn: The New Marketing Rules -- Jonathan Gabay
  Brand Forensics founder Jonathan Gabay shares his insights for brands eager to from the recession
   
 
May 28, 2010 Mom’s the Word: Social Media and Mothers -- Avi Savar
  Big Fuel Communications CEO Avi Savar shares the company's best practices for brands targeting women, especially moms, through social media marketing campaigns
   
 
May 21, 2010 Banking in Asia Hits the Reset Button -- Robert Allen
  Why the global financial crisis presents an opportunity for banking brands to win market share in Asia
   
 
Apr 9, 2010 Curated Crowdsourcing: The Next Big Thing? -- Andrew Meehan
  Will crowdsourcing garner mass appeal?
   
 
Mar 10, 2010 Beyond Mad Men: It’s Time for Brand School -- Rex Whisman
  Why Mad Men is old school.
   
 
Jan 15, 2010 Become One of the All-Too-Few Brands that Matter -- Ted Mininni
  How creating excitement creates profits.