linked in facebook twitter rss

  • Interbrand
  • Brandchannel

your chance!
your chance!
Martha Stewart Omnimedia Brand

 

  Martha Talks
Martha Talks
In the dog house
June 16, 2003

This week's webwatch is at the crossroads of two of the most interesting aspects of brand management: celebrity marketing and crisis management.

Any corporate management team would react swiftly if its brand were engulfed in a scandal that could associate its name with negative connotations. When the brand name is made of flesh and blood, as in the case of

 
celebrities, the situation gets more complex and fluid. Celebrities are not mere products; they are human beings with both the qualities we admire and the weaknesses that make them human. Too many faux-pas, and the name quickly loses its panache and reputation.

Understandably, many celebrities therefore try to control their "brand" name as much as possible, so as to manage and build up their brand equity carefully. The unflattering self -- whether real or perceived -- is then relegated to private life, as it should be, unless voyeurism and subsidiary agendas take over.

With the wave of corporate scandals in the background, Martha Stewart, a celebrity home designer, was allegedly involved in illegal insider trading on December 27, 2001. The shares, related to drug-maker ImClone, lost 16 percent of their stock price by the end of December 31, following an announcement that its cancer drug Erbitux received a negative review from the US Food and Drug Administration (FDA). Since then, Stewart's dealings with the US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) and the justice system have received considerable media attention. Moreover, the stock of Martha Stewart Living Omnimedia, Inc., (ticker: MSO) of which Stewart was the CEO and Chairman, has lost about 50 percent of its value.

On June 4, 2003, the SEC formally filed charges against Stewart, to which she pleaded not guilty. At the same time Stewart is pleading in the court of public opinion on a new website MarthaTalks.com.

 
 
Martha Talks Compared with the middle-class flair that became the hallmark of Martha Stewart's designs, her personal site is sober and understated. Reaching out to her audience, she does not “talk,” but she does write, and demonstrates the tenacity of a self-made entrepreneur as well as the humanity of someone who is hurt.

The site is plain white, enhanced by Stewart's trademark apple-green ink and accents, with no images, save one picture on the front page. At the time of this review, the picture was Martha and her two dogs Paw Paw and TaTu. This week it is "Big Martha and Little Martha," and it might change on a regular basis. On the front page, Stewart thanks her audience for its support, mentioning the more than 9 million hits and nearly 50,000 visitors that the site logged in just a few days.

The simple navigation menu occupies the top, and does not roll over. It covers the following topics: Read my Letter, Email Martha, Notes to Martha, Other Voices, Setting the Record Straight. It appears that the site was pieced together in a rush. As a result, the overall impression connotes "genuine," which is a fundamental attribute to open the communication bridge with her audience.

Unfortunately, it is difficult to figure out the positive impact that the site may have beyond that. It is akin to a message in a big green bottle adrift in the middle of the ocean.

 
*Due to the constantly changing environment of websites, some reviews may no longer reflect the current website for this brand.
 commenting closed Add Social Bookmark bookmark  print
 suggest topic  recommend ( 7 )  email

  brandchannel Digital Watch archive   2012  |  2011  |  2010  |  2009  |  2008  |  2007  |  2006  |  2005  |  2004  | 2003  |  2002  |  2001
 
 
Dec 22, 2003 Red Envelope - arrives -- VG
  Does Red Envelope deliver?
   
 
Dec 15, 2003 FTD.com vs. 1-800-FLOWERS.COM - budding heads -- Abram Sauer
  This holiday season, will you say it with FTD or 1-800-flowers.com?
   
 
Dec 8, 2003 IgoUgo.com - goes -- Diane O'Brien
  IgoUgo is going places by creating a site stocked with unbiased travel info.
   
 
Dec 1, 2003 Parmalat - Milks it
  Does Parmalat’s website flow well?
   
 
Nov 24, 2003 Weight Watchers - Gets points
  Weight Watchers scores extra points for a well proportioned site.
   
 
Nov 17, 2003 Consumer Reports - First rate -- Diane O'Brien
  ConsumerReports.org gets tested and approved.
   
 
Nov 10, 2003 Redken - Radiates
  Redken upholds its exclusive image online
   
 
Nov 3, 2003 Heineken.com vs. Budweiser.com - Taste test -- Abram Sauer
  One can drain a six-pack before reaching the end of Budweiser or Heineken.com
   
 
Oct 27, 2003 The Holy See - In nubibus
  Exactly whom is the Holy See hoping to congregate online?
   
 
Oct 20, 2003 Oxfam - Raises awareness
  Oxfam sends a clear message.
   
 
Oct 13, 2003 Circuit City - Current
  Circuit City achieves customer satisfaction online.
   
 
Oct 6, 2003 Mahindra Scorpio - Struts
  While Mahindra Scorpio steers well offline, online it appears to have lost its way
   
 
Sep 29, 2003 Capital One Auto Finance - Stalls
  Capital One Auto Finance misses an opportunity to excite the viewer with its website.
   
 
Sep 22, 2003 Johnnie Walker vs. Jack Daniel’s - Stately vs. sauced -- Abram Sauer
  Johnnie Walker and Jack Daniels get a taste test as we visit their sites for a comparison between posh and pished.
   
 
Sep 15, 2003 Frette - Good in bed -- Vivian Manning-Schaffel
  Wrap yourself between the folds of Italian linen supplier Frette.com
   
 
Sep 8, 2003 iTunes vs. BuyMusic - Sound off -- Abram Sauer
  iTunes and BuyMusic compete to ring your bell
   
 
Sep 1, 2003 Casino - Snake eyes
  France’s supermarket Casino takes a gamble on the web.
   
 
Aug 25, 2003 National Geographic - explore -- brandchannel
  National Geographic proves that educational sites don’t have to be boring.
   
 
Aug 18, 2003 Jet Airways - Cruising
  Jet Airways flies high online.
   
 
Aug 11, 2003 Accenture - Accountable
  Accenture carries its professional service mission on to its website.
   
 
Aug 4, 2003 Vespa - Right turn
  Italy’s Vespa navigates the web.
   
 
Jul 28, 2003 Marriott - Four star -- Charlotte Jane Dyson
  At your service: Marriott.com.
   
 
Jul 21, 2003 Ryanair - Sky's the limit
  Ryanair flies through cyberspace as a do-it-yourself, no-frills carrier.
   
 
Jul 14, 2003 Damiani - Star studded -- Vivian Manning-Schaffel
  Damiani's reputation for superb design is seen in its website as well as its jewlery.
   
 
Jul 7, 2003 American Express - Charged
  American Express doesn’t leave home without its brand.
   
 
Jun 30, 2003 Chloé - Trés chic -- Vivian Manning-Schaffel
  What's the look at chloé.com?
   
 
Jun 23, 2003 World Health Organization - cares -- Abram Sauer
  Is a visit to WHO.org an infectious activity?
   
 
Jun 9, 2003 Royal Sundaram - Hum drum
  Is Royal Sundaram “beyond expectation” or caught by a sticky wicket?
   
 
Jun 2, 2003 Hooters Air - Busting out -- Diane O'Brien
  Hooters joins the mile-high club.
   
 
May 26, 2003 Roland Garros - Brand slam
  The French Open kicks off in Paris, we keep score at RolandGarros.com
   
 
May 19, 2003 Swarovski - A gem
  Swarovski.com creates a new world on the web
   
 
May 12, 2003 CRY (Child Relief & You) - A relief
  CRY.org happily hosts a successful nonprofit brand online.
   
 
May 5, 2003 Staples - Works
  Packed with supplies, Staples.com does its best to organize online.
   
 
Apr 28, 2003 Roma - When in rome...
  Roma uses the web to spin bureaucracy.
   
 
Apr 21, 2003 Burpee - Fertile
  Burpee sows the seeds of a great brand online.
   
 
Apr 14, 2003 Steinway & Sons - off key -- VG
  Does Steinway.com need tuning?
   
 
Apr 7, 2003 Maxell - Memorable
  Is Maxell's site memborable?
   
 
Mar 31, 2003 Titan - Losing face
  It’s time for Titan to work on its online brand.
   
 
Mar 24, 2003 Sony - High tech
  Sony.jp uses the latest technology and the oldest (and best) branding techniques to display its product.
   
 
Mar 17, 2003 Clicquot - Comme ci, comme ça
  Is Clicquot's web offering sparkling or flat?
   
 
Mar 10, 2003 Botox - Numb -- Charlotte Jane Dyson
  Allergan's Botox.com misses an opportunity to flatter a vain audience.
   
 
Mar 3, 2003 IKEA - Functional -- Vivian Manning-Schaffel
  Is IKEA.com well furnished?
   
 
Feb 24, 2003 Maersk - off course -- VG
  Does Maersk.com chart a steady course online?
   
 
Feb 17, 2003 Jimmy Choo - Bare Feat -- Charlotte Jane Dyson
  Normally, standing proud, JimmyChoo.com limps along on the Web.
   
 
Feb 10, 2003 Godiva.com - Love bytes
  Browsing for a Valentine gift? Godiva.com delivers.
   
 
Feb 3, 2003 Carrefour - Stocked
  The aisles of Carrefour.com are stocked with a strong representation of its brand.
   
 
Jan 27, 2003 Mini - Bug free -- Abram Sauer
  How does Mini compare with its car lot companion Beetle online?
   
 
Jan 20, 2003 NFL.com - Fumbles
  Are you ready for some football? American football, that is, coming to you straight from NFL.com.
   
 
Jan 13, 2003 Boots - Take as directed
  Does popular UK chemist Boots enhance wellbeing with its online offering?
   
 
Jan 6, 2003 Burton - Carves the corduroy -- Cristi Barnet
  Take a ride on Burton.com